Coroners' Recommendations on Maternal Deaths in England and Wales Routinely Ignored, Research Shows
Recent research indicates that prevention guidance issued by coroners after maternal deaths in England and Wales are not being implemented.
Key Findings from the Research
Researchers from a leading London university analyzed prevention of future deaths documents issued by medical examiners concerning pregnant women and new mothers who passed away between 2013 and 2023.
The study, published in a prominent medical journal, identified 29 prevention of future death reports involving maternal deaths, but discovered that approximately 65% of these recommendations were not implemented.
Alarming Data and Trends
Two-thirds of these deaths took place in hospitals, with more than half of the women dying post-delivery.
The most common causes of death included:
- Severe bleeding
- Problems during the first trimester
- Suicide
Coroners' Main Worries
Issues raised by medical examiners commonly featured:
- Failure to deliver suitable treatment
- Lack of case escalation
- Insufficient staff training
Response Rates and Regulatory Requirements
Healthcare providers, like other regulatory organizations, are legally required to reply to the coroner within eight weeks.
However, the study discovered that only 38% of PFDs had published responses from the institutions they were addressed to.
Global and National Perspective
According to latest figures from the World Health Organization, approximately two hundred sixty thousand women died during and after pregnancy and childbirth, even though the majority of these instances could have been prevented.
While the overwhelming majority of maternal deaths occur in developing nations, the risk of maternal death in developed nations is on average 10 per 100,000 births.
In the UK, the maternal death rate for recent years was 12.82 per 100,000 live births.
Expert Commentary
"The concerns of mothers and pregnant people must be taken seriously," stated the principal researcher of the study.
The academic emphasized that prevention reports should be included as part of the upcoming official inquiry into NHS maternity and neonatal care to ensure that the same failures and deaths do not happen repeatedly.
Personal Loss Illustrates Widespread Problems
One relative shared their story: "Postnatal mental health issues can be fatal if not dealt with swiftly and properly."
They added: "Unless insights aren't being learned then it's probable other mothers are being missed by the system."
Formal Reaction
A spokesperson from the national maternity investigation stated: "The objective of the official review is to identify the systemic issues that have led to poor outcomes, including fatalities, in maternal healthcare."
A government health department spokesperson described the failure of institutions to respond promptly to prevention reports as "unreasonable."
They confirmed: "We are implementing urgent measures to improve safety across maternal healthcare, including through advanced monitoring systems and programmes to prevent brain injuries during childbirth."